The Enterprise gets pulled to bits! Bones and Spock do some actual bonding! And the Beastie Boys save the day! It’s certainly not dull, but does Star Trek Beyond live up to the hype?
Well that was a blast! And what a cracking plot twist! Nicely foreshadowed, but I didn’t see it coming. I assumed that as Krall ‘consumed’ more human energy, he would end up imbibing our human perspective, and realise the error of his ways. The way things actually played out was far more interesting. Uhura figuring it out with the video log sent a shiver down my spine. Most baddies become less engaging the more we learn about them, whereas Krall becomes more compelling as the story progresses. Excellent writing, and a brilliant performance from Idris Elba.
I absolutely loved the design of Krall’s spaceships. They looked menacing even when stood still, and had a really fresh approach to space warfare. No elegant laser battles here – the whole ship is a weapon, literally fired into enemy vessels, tearing into the hull and disgorging soldiers into the belly of the ship. It was pleasingly visceral and low tech, and very efficiently tells you a lot about the kind of people we’re dealing with. The design also gave rise to some cracking visuals, with the ‘swarm’ attacks making an interesting inversion of the usual one massive-scary-ship idea. It also, with a pleasing irony, suggests the idea of strength coming from unity. Krall’s crew are destroyed, after all, when the link between them is interrupted.
The plot is very well managed, keeping things tight but not too manic. There’s very little planet-hopping here, and the main thrust of the plot is very straightforward: get off the planet and protect Yorktown. Splitting everyone up is a neat trick, preventing things becoming too focussed on one ‘hero’ who figures it all out and saves the day. Instead, there is a nice momentum as each group learns something useful, working to regroup and then move forward – again, victory through teamwork.
That isn’t just a moral of the story, some practical lesson tacked onto the end. It really shows throughout the film as the characters interact and relationships develop. Spock and Kirk re-establish just how well they work together, but Spock and Uhura are also great team. As are Kirk and Chekov. And Scotty and Wee-man, obviously. Even Jayla finds a place as part of the crew. Family and belonging are themes the previous films have considered before, but Director Justin Lin really brings that to the fore, and with great success.
As some relationships develop over time, others are cut short. The death of Leonard Nimoy is beautifully worked into the story, as our Spock struggled with the death of Ambassador Spock. Does this mean his place is now on New Vulcan? In a lovely tribute, we’re shown an image of Ambassador Spock back on the Enterprise with the rest of his crew, which inspires our Spock to stay where he is. The death of Anton Yelchin, who was sadly killed after filming had completed, is also acknowledged with a toast ‘to absent friends’. A simple, but very moving tribute, elegantly handled.
With all the weighty ideas, the tone of the film is never ponderous. We get some brilliant laugh out loud moments, mostly from Bones, together with a pleasing sense of self-awareness: Kirk says that the voyage is starting to feel ‘a little episodic’. There’s also an infectious sense of optimism – Yorktown is no grim, industrial outpost, but a sophisticated, glistening, bustling metropolis. There are rivers, and trees and skyscrapers! Bones likens it to a snow globe, floating in space. He means to suggest its isolation and vulnerability, but he inadvertently conveys how pretty it is. A delicate space bauble, filled with light and life. The future looks cool.
One of the best things about Beyond is that, the more I’ve thought about it, the more I’ve enjoyed it. Ideas play off against each other, and reinforce each other, all handled with real narrative and visual flair: ‘We have to change, or we end up fighting the same wars.’ If our ancestors could see us now, how would they judge us? Kirk’s renewed sense of purpose comes from realising just how important Starfleet is, how peace and progress require constant drive and work. There was a lovely shot of Kirk in his escape pod, watching through the glass as the shattered Enterprise crash lands on the unknown world. His home, his family, and his purpose – all taken from him in a single swoop. Time to start fighting for what matters.
Any quibbles? I couldn’t help but notice the absence of Carole Marcus from Into Darkness. Did she not fancy the five year mission after all? Most of the ‘bad’ aliens were ugly, and the ‘good’ aliens were pretty – bit of a cliché, though hardly a big deal. And, while things mostly looked great, the CGI was a bit wobbly on occasion, most notably when we first see Kirk and Jayla on the motorbike.
But I was either moved, amused, or on the edge of my seat for the entire run-time. 2 hours flew by, and I was left hoping to see a lot more of Kirk and his crew. Justin Lin is used to helming long-lasting franchises, so who knows? I feel like we’re just getting started.
What did you think? Is there anything I missed? Did you enjoy ‘the beats and shouting’? Which enemy would you like to see the Enterprise up against next? Should the role of Chekov be recast, or should the character be written out? Let me know!